On October 27, 2026, Ares Capital Corporation agreed to acquire MidCap Financial Investment Corporation in a stock and cash transaction valued at about $2.6 billion of enterprise value. The headline offer of $10.88 per share is a 30.1% premium to MFIC's closing price the day before. It is also roughly 15% below the net asset value (NAV) of about $12.86 per share that MFIC reported preliminarily for September 30. Both statements are accurate, and the gap between them is a useful lesson for any owner thinking about what a fair price means.
MFIC is a business development company (BDC), a publicly traded vehicle that lends to middle-market companies. A BDC reports a net asset value each quarter, which is the fair value of its loans and other holdings minus its debt, divided by the number of shares. For a company like this, NAV is the closest thing to a book-value anchor, and the share price often trades below it when investors want a larger return than the portfolio is expected to deliver.
Ares Capital is offering $10.88 per MFIC share: about $1.21 in cash from a subsidiary of Ares Management and about $9.67 in Ares Capital stock. Measured against the market price, MFIC holders receive a 30.1% premium, or 25.8% over the 30-day volume-weighted average price. Measured against NAV, they receive about 85 cents on the dollar. Neither framing is wrong. They answer different questions: what the shares were worth to the market last week, and what the underlying portfolio is carried at on the books.
Most owners of private companies do not have a daily share price, so the market premium has no direct counterpart. What they do have are anchors of their own: a prior valuation, an offer from an earlier process, a multiple a friend in the industry received, or the amount they have in mind for retirement. Each anchor makes a new offer look better or worse before any analysis begins.
The Ares and MFIC pricing shows how this works. A board explaining the deal to shareholders can lead with the 30.1% premium. A shareholder who bought at NAV can lead with the 15% discount. Both are describing the same $10.88. In a sale of a private business, the buyer will tend to present the reference point that makes the offer look strongest, which is why an owner benefits from establishing an independent view of value first.
The consideration here is mostly stock, and the exchange ratio is built with a mechanism worth understanding. Ares Capital shares are valued at the greater of its own NAV per share or its market price. MFIC holders share in 50% of any Ares Capital premium to NAV, up to 104.5% of NAV, and the maximum exchange valuation is capped at 102.25% of NAV. MFIC is also expected to pay a special dividend before closing to distribute undistributed taxable income, and the stock portion of the price is reduced dollar for dollar for that dividend.
For an owner, the point is that a stated price in a deal with stock consideration is a formula, not a fixed amount. What the seller receives depends on the buyer's value at the time of closing, any caps and floors written into the exchange terms, and distributions made between signing and closing. Closing is expected in the first half of 2027, so the value delivered will depend on market conditions over roughly six months. Sellers who accept stock should ask for the formula to be modeled under several outcomes before signing.
Valuation professionals usually look at a business through more than one lens: what comparable companies trade for, what comparable transactions paid, and what the business's own cash flows or assets support. When the lenses disagree, the disagreement is information. An offer well below asset value deserves a question about why, and an offer well above it deserves a question about what the buyer expects to earn from those assets.
This matters outside financial companies. An owner of a business with significant real estate, equipment, inventory, or an investment portfolio can compare a proposed price with the adjusted value of those assets. A buyer paying less than asset value may be pricing in a risk the owner has not considered, or may be taking advantage of an owner who has not looked at the assets separately. A fairness opinion, which is an independent view of whether a price is fair from a financial standpoint, is one way a board or special committee documents this analysis.
Ares Capital says the deal would lift its portfolio to more than $31 billion at fair value, add more than 200 positions, and expand its sponsor relationships to more than 600. It expects the transaction to be modestly accretive to core earnings per share, and Wells Fargo has agreed to provide $750 million of additional secured financing, subject to conditions. In other words, the buyer is paying for scale and relationships, and the price reflects what those are worth to Ares Capital, not only what MFIC's portfolio is worth on its own.
Sellers in other industries face the same logic. The value of a business to a specific buyer includes cost savings, customers, and capabilities the buyer cannot easily build itself. That is the part of the price an owner can negotiate, and it is the part that a headline premium to a prior valuation tends to obscure.

The Ares Capital and MidCap Financial agreement is a price that is 30.1% above the market and about 15% below net asset value, depending on which number is used. Owners should expect their own offers to be framed in whichever way favors the buyer, and should form an independent view of value across several methods before negotiating. When part of the price is paid in stock, the formula and the time to closing matter as much as the headline number.